Are Carter Family Sex Claims Believable?

Our previous poll asking which Carter family claim do you believe is most likely false saw 35.5% say they’re all true, while 19% said they were all false. As for specifics, the claim people seemed to have the hardest time believing was that Aaron Carter claimed to have had sex with Hilary Duff, followed by Nick Carter’s claim to have had sex with Ashlee Simpson to get revenge from his then cheating ex, Paris Hilton.