Christina Aguilera Gifted, Britney A Pop Regret

In an online chat with readers, Elysa Gardner of USA Today was asked to weigh in on ’s negative remarks on pop rivals , Destiny’s Child star Beyonce Knowles, and . “I’ll say this much: Christina is the most naturally gifted singer of the three,” the music critic said. “Not always crazy about her material, or her style, but the girl has a powerful and very musical voice. As for Britney… I think she would have been better off had she not been dragged into show business as a kid, and allowed to forge a more normal life. But perhaps I’ll get into that in a future article.” Read the entire transcript here.

Related News

11 thoughts on “Christina Aguilera Gifted, Britney A Pop Regret

  1. rangergirl says:

    Some of the reporter’s comments could apply to the other pop singers as well especially the one about not being dragged into show biz as a kid. But it seems most of them loved to perform as kids -so who knows.

  2. Angel_Jtfan says:

    so true about the Britney thing. the only reason she’s in the business is because of her “good”looks.

  3. Lava33 says:

    Not another dumb post about “Why Britney sucks” blah blah. I like Britney and Christina, Christina has a better voice obviously, but people like who they like.

  4. Hotstar says:

    Who is this b!tch and why should anyone care about her opinion? It is really rude to suggest that some should not have gone into show business. If she doesn’t like her music, then she shouldn’t listen to it. And all the Christina fans should keep in mind that she criticized Tina’s style and her material, so evidently she wasn’t too impressed by Stripped.

  5. BadAss4Backstreet says:

    Booey-ah…… THANK YOU VERY MUCH! Put the topic to rest….THIS is the truth! She may have criticized a couple aspects about Christina, but she said Britney just needs to go away…. It’s quite sad that NO ONE with ANY credibility WHATSOEVER respects Britney….yet her fans BLINDLY look away!

  6. getalifeyall says:

    Mariah Carey is obviously the most gifted singer compared to Janet Jackson and Madonna, but both of those ladies are outselling her in the moment. My point being is that best voice doesn’t always mean the best artist. People with incredible voices are given a gift. They don’t have to work for anything. Its the artists that have to work and be creative that stick around.

  7. JMAX says:

    I don’t know where that “pop regret” thing came from, she never said that. She just said Britney shouldn’t have started so early, but Christina started early too. And she said “the kiss” was stupid, but Christina kissed Madonna too. And if you Christina fans would actually read the article, you would see that once again Christina is being praised for her voice, and bashed for her music, style, and everything else.

  8. angelinajolieXtina01 says:

    to be honest I really like Christina Aguilera’s style it is very unique batta then stickin to safe and borin (most artist) Christina is gifted and she uses it in a positive way Britney should of never been a singer but a backup dancer sayin it to be honest not in a negitive way. Christina rox and her voice

  9. FuturePast says:

    I know lots of people that didn’t like stripped and how many people here have mentioned that, although she has a proficient voice, it grates on the nerves after 5 minutes. And her material is mundane. She and clay Aiken, along with Kelly Clarkson need to head for Broadway.

  10. Fashionista says:

    You know what no matter who she is what she is saying is absolutely true, yes Christina’s style or materials may not suit everyone but at the end of the day she has the TALENT that not so many “POPSTARS aka SINGERS” have. Since when did looking good make you a singer/artist? As for Pink all I can say is LOSER she thinks she’s hard but really underneath all that I see the *****, she’s just frontin’ with all that attitude. Britney; a complete waste of space there are some many TALENTED people out there who deserve to be where Britney is, yes she’s worked hard you can’t deny her that but the UNDERDOGS out there are the real TALENTS. People what has happened to HAVUNG TALENT, where has it all GONE?

  11. Julie816 says:

    Elysa Gardner is just a pathetic columnist for USA today who don’t know anything about music. Is she a singer? No, Elysa can tell musical talent as Jessica Simpson telling tuna from chicken. Look at the ugly wh*re on the website; she doesn’t have a chance in the business so she’s ranting like cry baby Christina in blender. Maybe someone should slit Elysa Gardner throat and maybe she’ll think twice about opening her big mouth.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.