EW Grades ‘American Idol’ Performances

Jessica Shaw of Entertainment Weekly graded last night’s ‘American Idol’ performances, where each of the four finalists got to perform twice. Shaw said Tamyra Gray’s rendition of Patti LaBelle’s ‘New Attitude’ rated a B, while she scored an A- with ‘Feel the Fire.’ She gave Nikki McKibbin a B for ‘Mary Jane’ and a B+ for ‘I’m the Only One’. Read more, including her grades for the Kelly Clarkson and Justin Guarini performances here.