Josh Shines, While Kim And Clay Stumble

Jessica Shaw of Entertainment Weekly weighed in on last night’s episode of ‘American Idol’, proclaiming that Kimberley Locke and Clay Aiken will likely be the bottom two, while Josh Gracin should move on. She said of Gracin, “I was all ready for the guy to butcher another song and damn it if he didn’t eke out another week of national attention. Don’t get me wrong: ‘Jive Talking’ was a travesty. But ‘To Love Somebody’ was at least four billion times better than anything he’s ever sung this competition. It’s sort of like watching that dog skateboard. He’s not particularly great at it, but you’re so impressed that he didn’t fall on his face that you have to give him props. Should Josh go home? Absolutely. Will he? Sadly, I think not.” Read more.