Star magazine reports Nick Carter was spotted by a group of pre-teen girls playing tennis in Los Angeles, where they asked the Backstreet Boys star for autographs. When the sweaty Nick took off his shirt, their interest changed. One girl gasped, “Look, he’s fat!” pointing towards Carter’s love handles. Her friends responded, “You’re right. He IS fat!” The fickle fans made gaggin noises and quickly left the stunned singer, without any autographs.