What Is The Britney Vs. Christina Argument About, Really?

Contributed anonymously:

Why is it always vs. or vice versa? I like them both but as far as great talents and great artists go, neither is respected in the business. They’re just starting to write and perform their own songs, until they prove that they have songwriter talent they will never be respected in the business (sorry but being beautiful is not a talent). You all act like these are the only 2 female artists in the world, always comparing and pitting them against each other. What about other female artists who have written and performed their own songs from the start? Artists who have proven themselves such as Madonna, Jewel, Alanis Morissette, Nora Jones, Janet Jackson, , Carley Simon, The Bangles, Pat Bennitar, etc. Christina is just starting to prove that she has the potential to write her own songs. Next month, Britney will try to prove that she has that potential too. As far as images go, they have the same image (whether you want to admit it or not, they do).

I don’t think Britney’s copying Christina or Christina’s copying Britney, if anything they’re copying Madonna. She’s done everything they have and more with a lot more style, pizzazz, and umph than these 2 will ever have. In my opinion: Christina fans are upset because no matter what Christina does, Britney gets 10X more publicity than Christina (the kiss). Britney fans are upset because no matter what Britney does she gets bashed for it, even when it’s something everyone does.

I don’t understand how you can say you hate someone but you read everything about him/her, download all him/her interviews and view all him/her pictures. How can you be that consumed with someone you hate, someone that has no idea you even exist. You guys argue back and forth for nothing. Christina fans are gonna stay Christina fans, no matter what you say. Britney fans are gonna stay Britney fans, no matter what you say. So why bother arguing about it. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think everyone should like everyone but you all take this FAKE Christina/Britney rivalry too far.

I really just don’t understand the argument you guys have here every single day. What is it about, really.


Related News

11 thoughts on “What Is The Britney Vs. Christina Argument About, Really?

  1. StayGoneBeautiful says:

    -Rolls Eyes- You’re never going to understand it. Intelligent and mature people with sense simply can’t understand the inner workings of the ignorantly immature way of thinking, so don’t bother. Most people come here looking for a fight out of pure boredom, others visit in hopes of finding some juicy gossip about their favorite music act and get defensive when they see something belittling to their idol, while others just come to check the site out. To question the mere existence of the arguments is to ponder the motivations. Like I said, you’ll never understand why some a-holes have to come here and start trouble.

  2. Kizzardkid says:

    Okay enough with these stupid posts, but I do agree with you on some count. The only think I hate about Britney is that she never sings live and yet people think she’s the greatest thing ever, just like Jennifer Lopez, but truth is these girls can’t sing. I do think that Britney is an amazing performer but she has nothing to give with that tiny voice, but yet I really have nothing against her. and I think Christina is awesome, When I heard she would be writing all her stuff on her new record, I’ll admit that I didn’t think it would be that great, but “Stripped” is really one of the best albums ever, it is a must have CD, even if you’re not a fan. And another thing, you left out Mariah Carey out of those artist you named, she should have been first.

  3. perfectly-imperfect says:

    “Christina fans are upset because no matter what Christina does, Britney gets 10X more publicity than Christina (the kiss). Britney fans are upset because no matter what Britney does she gets bashed for it, even when it’s something everyone does.” …so true. “I don’t understand how you can say you hate someone but you read everything about him/her, download all him/her interviews and view all him/her pictures. How can you be that consumed with someone you hate, someone that has no idea you even exist. wow, this is probably directed at jimmypee, babet, Xtina-Dirrty, and all those other turds. The simple truth is, they have nothing else to do. They most likely lead very depressing and melancholy lives, and bashing Britney is one of their few pleasures. So, why deprive them of it? You shouldn’t care too much about people like the ones I’ve mentioned, since no one in their real ‘lives’ probably gives 2 sh**s about them. Sad, but true. All in all, this is Popdirt.com, so you shouldn’t expect this trash talking to stop. Just…get over it.

  4. mel_melanie says:

    Well they are both whores and sluts. and now Christina is a lesbian so I don’t see then not getting along.

  5. XtinaFighter says:

    These posts are so old and so annoying, they all say the same thing~and guess what Britney fans are not going to stop comparing Christina to Britney and Christina fans are not going to stop comparing Britney to Christina so get over it people! its not going to stop!

  6. anti_avril says:

    mel_melanie you know you want to screw Christina and Britney so stop hating. Britney and Christina may not have the same voice but they have there own type of singing. Britney is more about having fun and dancing, when Christina is more about just straight out singing. Britney is more fun to watch but they both are great to listen to. I just ay stuff bout Christina because I like Britney’s music because its fun, Christina’s is like about her abusive life. I want to feel positive, not negative.

  7. mel_melanie says:

    Right that’s why I hate them to death. You are the one who’s sticking up for them you stupid. I HATE Christina and Britney just because there sluts and and well Britney can not sing at all.

  8. HoneyRain says:

    Take away Britney’s looks, body, and dance moves and what have you got left?.. 2 AA batteries Britney can have all the publicity, popularity votes, and record sales she wants.. because Christina will ALWAYS have the talent, the respect, and artistic ability face it.. Britney CAN NOT SURVIVE THE INDUSTRY WITHOUT HER LOOKS AND DANCING! Christina has done many photo shoots and videos that people have labelled “unflattering” and “obscene”.. but guess what.. my girl is STILL here selling records, inspiring millions, and keeping the public guessing. not ONE of her videos have been even similar to the other. Christina has turned off millions of people.. but guess what.. my girl is STILL outselling hundreds of other artists.. and no she hasn’t been provocative in every video. If Britney had ONE hair out of place and didn’t dance.. she wouldn’t sell crap!! I’m always impressed by someone who can succeed when they’re both beautiful AND ugly.

  9. otownfreak11 says:

    Ok I’m a Christina fan all the way! and I know Britney has sold more albums then Christina…blah…blah…blah…but the thing I don’t get is Britney is showing up half naked and some comments are, “She’s beautiful…She’s amazing” Christina started showing more skin comments were, “What a whore..skank..” as far as I’m concerned it comes down to the music and who has the better voice and staying power..i think Britney’s next album she HAS to have something new she can’t keep repeating her pop tart-ish sound… When these 2 girls are 30 years old I THINK Christina will still be around *knock on wood* because of her voice…Britney MAY still be in the industry in some other way…. because she can’t dance and sing her whole life and since she started smoking and all we don’t know if her dancing will be in tip top shape like it has been through out the years….and Britney does have a ok voice but it doesn’t even compare to Christina.

    And one more thing someone said something about how Christina was jealous of the attention of the Britney Madonna kiss or whatever the comment was…the reason why Christina didn’t get a lot of attention for that is because by the time we saw Justin’s reaction they were done kissing

  10. hellahooked says:

    The only reason people compare them is because of some of their messed up fans. “Christina fans are upset because no matter what Christina does, Britney gets 10X more publicity than Christina (the kiss). Britney fans are upset because no matter what Britney does she gets bashed for it, even when it’s something everyone does.” Exactly, wow so true.

  11. CARPEDIEM says:

    Damn, this is dead on. Neither Christina or Britney are respected in the music business. They are not serious artist, any real fan of music knows it. They are just pretty faces, that’s it. End of discussion… But please, no more essays.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

popdirt.com