Will One Bad Performance Kill Clay Aiken?

Jessica Shaw of Entertainment Weekly shared her thoughts on last night’s ‘American Idol’. She says, “Each contestant had one great performance, but other than that, there wasn’t an obvious superstar.” As for Clay Aiken’s flub of his first performance, Shaw says, “After that hideous ‘Vincent,’ all I could think was Clay just became this year’s Tamyra. A bad song choice and buh-bye. Granted, a random choice wasn’t his fault, but how could the guy forget his words? Sure the song is hardly memorable, but even I knew that stupid ‘Now I understand…’ part.” Read more.