Extra: Producer Says Antonella’s Fate In Voters’ Hands

Are rumors true that Antonella Barba could be booted by ‘American Idol’ because of her racy photo scandal? Don’t count on it. According to ‘Idol’ producer Nigel Lythgoe, her fate is in the voters’ hands. “Without question, any competition like this is part popularity competition,” Lythogoe tells ‘Extra’.

Update: Antonella was sitting with the other girls tonight and Ryan pointed to them and said these girls will sing tomorrow night.